Reviews
Read our rave reviews or leave one of your own!
Simmas Bakery has to make the best cheesecake on Earth! We used them for our wedding 30 years ago when it was a tiny little store that had just started out. Now, my daughter just got married and we used them again for her wedding (and lots of times in between). They still use the original recipe and why wouldn't they, it is perfection! Thank you for an amazing wedding cake!
Shari K
14:32 21 Jun 19
Simmas Bakery has to make the best cheesecake on Earth! We used them for our wedding 30 years ago when it was a tiny little store that had just started out. Now, my daughter just got married and we used them again for her wedding (and lots of times in between). They still use the original recipe and why wouldn't they, it is perfection! Thank you for an amazing wedding cake!
Shari K
14:31 21 Jun 19
Unbelievable cheesecakes! Not cheap but quality costs folks and these are the best by far! Had a huge one made for an event and was not disappointed! Everyone raved about it. Has all my business from now on! 👍👏
Mike Hermes
21:39 13 May 19
I miss the quaint, old-school feel of the pre-renovation Simma's. Personal nostalgia aside, the new Simma's is clean, bright, and inviting. And most importantly nothing has changed about their bakery, which is absolutely some of the best you can buy anywhere. Their cheesecake is a must-try, but don't overlook some of their other specialties. In particular their carrot cake and red velvet cakes are absolutely great.If you happen to need a wedding cake, they do a great job with that as well. Excellent communication and fair prices. Zero complaints, and I can recommend Simma's without any reservations whatsoever. Our first experience with them making our wedding cake is what got us to continue coming back for years.
Benjamin Wilda
18:32 13 May 19
When I need a special dessert, Simma's is my favorite! The cheesecake is to die for! Thin chocolate cake base, raspberry layer topped with a luscious creamy cheesecake! The retail store on 68th street is sure to be busy....head for the ticket machine as soon as you walk in the door. The staff is friendly and efficiently waits on each customer so the crowd moves quickly! The price might seem a bit high, but believe me....it is worth every penny! Great assortment of other bakery as well! Beautifully decorated too! Don't expect any leftovers!
Kathy Wester
00:31 12 May 19
It pains me to have to write a negative review for Simma's because they have amazing quality in their cakes, but the service has always been extremely poor nearly every time we've gone there.They will probably not have your cake ready on-time if you order ahead (which is the point). They will probably not have the writing on your cake done, and they'll rush the job last minute and probably miss details that you requested on your cake styling. You'll also have 2-3 times the wait time of their walk-in customers. These things have happened several times for myself and my family.They did not offer any discount on our cakes for their mistakes... They've had ample chances and blown every one. I really hope someone in their management can shape up their operations.UPDATE:The owner personally called me the day after the incident took place to apologize. She reassured me she would talk to her staff about what happened, and to educate them on what they could've done better. She also offered me a gift card. I am quite pleased she reached out so quickly, and actually cared about making things right. I'll definitely be returning!
Anna Soderberg
15:27 06 May 19
Best cheesecake ever! Have to try the owner's recipe for french toast using their morning buns. Wow! Wonderful variety of specialty desserts. Cute upscale party supplies like candles and napkins that you won't find at Target or party store.
Mary Kubicek
04:39 09 Apr 19
I am very impressed with the service I got this past Sunday. My mom and I arrived at Simma's at 12:45pm, when they close at 12pm thinking that they actually close at 3pm. The lovely lady working let us in to get what we wanted and on our way out gave us oatmeal cookies for free. We were extremely grateful for the act of kindness and helpfulness. By the way, they have the best cheesecake but, who didn't know that! 🙂
Briana Sardina
19:22 08 Apr 19
Delicious cheesecakes... I've had them many times on the job. Plan to order soon for my son's birthday.
Tanika Knight
21:25 03 Apr 19
Best Bakery in town. Their cakes and pastries are always fresh and delicious. It is always a pleasure visiting.
Angie Caceres
23:22 02 Apr 19
Ordered cake for my daughter's b'day party. Awesome taste and texture, everyone at the party finished it all. The size they suggested for cake was on target with little left over for us.
Tejas Salunke
01:57 29 Mar 19
Highest quality baked goods, well kept, clean space, friendly staff. They do a nice job ... also try their very best to please. Will definately order from there again. Owner was super nice and answered all our questions.
Robert Chapman
03:51 11 Feb 19
Amazing cake!! They saved my now 10 year old sisters birthday during the bitter cold. We were not able to get her a cake but Simma's Bakery was able to deliver us there chocolate mousse cake. We are very grateful that even in the extreme weather they were open and had amazing desserts.
tristan peters
19:59 01 Feb 19
Best Cheesecake Cakes, I drive all the way from PortWashington, WI just to get a them for our Birthday Parties -my sister ordered it for my moms 60th Birthday and since then the last two years I have gone twice! Delicious and Just Beautiful.Darling Sharpe-
Darling Sharpe
03:04 01 Feb 19
Simma's has some of the finest cakes and pastries in Southeastern Wisconsin. Their innovative and delicious creations are top notch. A little pricey, if we're being honest here, but it's always a delightful dessert.
Lucas Winchowky
20:18 29 Dec 18
I've been going to Simmas for over 25 years and have not found a better bakery....I don't have to look, this is the best!!!!Not only for my family but have given cakes, apple and cranberry breads to co-workers and friends. They have loved these specialty cakes and bread. You can really make a great impression when they try these.You will not be disappointed as evidenced by other reviews.
Mitch Wakeland
23:44 22 Dec 18
This my absolute favorite cheesecake! We were introduced to Simma's wonderful treats shortly after she opened in Wauwatosa. Then, the cheesecake became a favorite for birthdays over the years. Still wonderful after all these years!
Ginger Davis
01:03 17 Dec 18
They have great cheesecakes. Been there multiple times and never had a bad experience. Love their products
Richard Knauer
19:46 14 Dec 18
High end bakery specializing in cheesecake. Cheesecake has a 1st layer cake with cheesecake filling, a thin raspberry jam layer covered with chocolate ganache. They have a delicious assortment of pastries, muffins, etc. Also make beautiful wedding and special occasion cakes. We love this bakery.
Helen Kirschbaum
16:56 13 Dec 18
One of the best bakeries in Milwaukee and even the country. Best cheesecake I've had. Their morning buns and Danish are phenomenal.
Thomas Zeise
17:48 27 Oct 18
My review serves 2 purposes: The 1st is to correct what I believe was a mistake of a 1* rating from Carolyn below. She detailed an amazing story of how Simma's came to her rescue and her intention in sharing her experience. I think it's important to give credit when people have done well, so I just wanted to assist in making sure Simma's received the appropriate rating for going the extra mile for their customer. Now, I haven't been to Simma's in years, but I was looking for them specifically because when I was working outside the home, I recall they had something like an Amazing Morning Bun that I've never found anywhere else. Unfortunately, I didn't find it on the menu so I don't know if they still carry them or if that was even the name of the product I am looking for. I just know that we used to put in a large order at least once a year for the office and I am craving them at home now.
Elfreda Travel Your DreamZ Long
17:05 20 Oct 18
Great bakery to drop in for some treats from the counter or to special order cakes from. Cheesecake is amazing!!
Jason Smith
23:20 17 Oct 18
Amazingly delicious bakery! But, the best thing about this bakery is the passion its owner has to make sure her customers are satisfied.. She takes customer service to a new level! Simmas is my new go-to bakery. Long live Simmas 😊
Pam McGuire
06:33 02 Oct 18
Phenomenal cheesecake. Great customer service... (Katie) Thank You. My wife's birthday was a big success.
wudpkr
22:10 19 Sep 18
The business is easy to locate, and there is available seating for patrons. Service was quick. It wasn't crowded and the pastries taste great
Olusegun Onanuga
13:29 17 Sep 18
Hands down my favorite bakery! I love seeing their beautiful creations which taste as good as they look. A visit always gives me new ideas for my own creations
Christine Batzer
20:16 23 Apr 18
I love this bakery!! The service is GREAT!! The baked goods are EXCELLENT! I recommend them to anyone looking for morning snacks and evening desserts.
Latasha Dotson
23:29 15 Mar 18
I drove down from Cedarburg (about a half hour ride) for the chocolate mousse cake. That's how awesome this bakery is. It is pricey, but when you make cakes, tortes, and assorted bakery the old-fashioned way using quality ingredients, you don't mind paying for the privilege of great tasting treats! The bakery has a small Café area where you can enjoy what you purchase. Be forewarned - weekends are extremely busy. But remember - it's worth the wait! Call ahead and prepay for cakes, etc. and you can walk in and go the prepaid line.
Richard Yanda
20:46 10 Mar 18
Very pleasant place to go. Workers are always friendly and helpful! Macaroons are absolutely delicious and my favorite!!
Heatz, COD & More!
22:19 16 Feb 18
I know this sounds crazy, but I had a blast buying cheesecake and 2 cupcakes. Ended up joking with other customers and their counter people. Best cheesecake around and a great crew.
Bill Payne
23:08 02 Feb 18
Must get some cheesecake!😀 They make some great gluten free cheesecake and other goodies too. Wonderful bakery and great service.
Marco Rainaldi
22:17 26 Dec 17
Totally remodeled and enlarged since my last visit. Always busy, always a favorite. Best cheesecake ever: creamy cheese over a chocalate cake crust, a layer of raspberry and topped with a thin chocolate coat. Outstanding vanilla birthday cake, buttercream frosting, and strawberry whipped cream filling.
Lynn Bauer
06:58 25 Dec 17
You won't regret a trip to Simma's. Their desserts, pastries, and cakes are gorgeous and their taste exceeds their beauty!
Allison Jones
04:52 16 Dec 17
The best bakery I've ever been to. Everything looks amazing, everything I had was delicious. What a treat!!
Nan Johnson
01:03 05 Dec 17
Best cheesecake hands down. Haven't had a chance to taste anything else cause I'm always coming for the cheesecake.
Ivorena Taylor
20:11 26 Sep 17
This is always our go to place when we need a cheesecake for special occasions. They have the best cheesecake in the entire Milwaukee area!! Love this place!
Clark Kropp
12:53 04 Sep 17
My husband and I did a 4 tier gluten free cheesecake for our wedding on June 3rd. The cake was amazing! All of our guests loved the cake. We had guests say that they don't even like sweets, but this was the best thing that they ever tasted. Most of our guests were also surprised to find out that it was gluten free because it was so good! I recommend working with Simma's for your wedding cake. Delivery and set up was included in everything, you just need to return the cake plates and you get your deposit back! Very tasty!
Sara Shumaker
14:18 08 Jun 17
Leave a Review
How Was Your Experience?
